Pushing
to Protect Student PrivacyRecently, two lawmakers continued
to press for student-privacy legislation by announcing the results of a new federal
report on commercialism in schools. Earlier this year, when introducing separate
privacy bills, both Sen. Chris Dodd, D-Conn., and Rep. George Miller, D-Calif.,
had called for the General Accounting Office study on the sale of products and
direct advertising in public schools. Because the report made
no recommendations, but only acknowledged that marketing professionals are increasingly
targeting children in public schools, Dodd and Miller plan to ask another agency
for further studies. The National Institute for Child Health and Development could
assess the actual impact of this commercialism on children, giving the legislators'
proposals more weight. What's
Privacy Got to Do with the ESEA?Miller's bill was attached
to the Elementary and Secondary Education Act in May, but whether it will remain
in the final version to be voted on by Congress is doubtful, officials say. The
bill, which Miller revamped after hearing opposition from educators, calls for
schools to secure parental consent before allowing the collection of student information
for commercial use. But Kids in the Know  the advocacy group
to which The Association of Educational Publishers (AEP) belongs  said even after
the revisions, the proposed rule still was too extensive. (Heaping more responsibility
on teachers and administrators could hinder student participation in some educational
activities, Kids said. And why put the federal government in charge of
matters that local districts can handle better?) Dodd remains
eager to add some privacy legislation to a current education bill this year. But
now, it seems unlikely that Congress will move at all this year on the $2.4 billion
act that reauthorizes education funding, Kids in the Know spokesman Rob Graham
said recently. And that would be the first time this funding will miss its deadline. Chalk
it up to politics, Graham said. "The Senate was unable to break the logjam
over gun-related amendments. The bill is no longer on the Senate floor." Until
the new legislation is in place, he said, the government will continue to fund
all education programs as it did last year. |